Goodbyes and connection
Preschool Separation Anxiety: Before You Offer Another Activity

Imagine a four-year-old standing beside her teacher after her dad has left. She is crying.
“Would you like to play with the trucks?” her teacher asks.
The child takes a red truck, then looks back toward the door.
“I want Dad.”
“How about your favorite book?”
The child glances at the cover.
“I want Dad.”
The teacher knows she likes both. It is tempting to keep looking for something that will hold her attention. But what happens to the comfort we offer when we keep trying to find the right distraction?
Pnina Klein and her colleagues observed 24 infants and toddlers at drop-off during their first three months in daycare.
They noticed a cycle: a toy briefly interrupted the crying. When the crying returned, the caregiver tried another distraction.
The children who cried most received more distraction and less warmth. Children who cried less received more affectionate words, touch and empathy.1
Make warmth your first response to a difficult goodbye. Acknowledge who the child misses, offer company, and let that connection continue as they begin to play.
At the classroom door, the teacher can set the book aside and sit beside the child.
When a child keeps asking for their parent, pause the suggestions and offer company.
“You wish Dad could stay. I'll sit with you.”
Sit beside the child and let them talk about home or sit quietly. If they reach for a truck or a book, offer to join them. Keep listening and responding if they bring up their parent again. You can talk about Dad while you build together.
Back at the classroom door, the teacher returns the book to the basket and sits beside the child.
“You wish Dad were here. Would you like to sit close to me?”
The child leans against her. After a while, she holds out a truck.
“Will you play with me?”
“Yes,” the teacher says. “Where are we going?”
Research and source notes
1. Pnina S. Klein, Ravit R. Kraft and Cilly Shohet (2010), Behaviour patterns in daily mother–child separations: possible opportunities for stress reduction, full text, especially pp. 392–393. Participants were 6–18 months old. Observations do not establish that distraction caused distress or that another response would stop it. ↩
